Insurance company excuses for not providing fair compensation after an accident

March 18, 2022

Insurance companies often have a multitude of excuses regarding why they will not pay for an injury that resulted from an accident. At Sarkisian Law Offices, we deal with their excuses and get results, so you can can focus on healing.

No Excuses

Common Excuses from Insurance Companies when dealing with injury claims 


When a family experiences the serious injury or death of a loved one, they often try to work with an insurance company without the assistance of an attorney. All too often they learn the hard way that insurance companies offer excuses instead of fair compensation. The following is a list of common excuses used by insurance companies, whether in the claims process or at trial:

Excuse No. 1:            “Even though there are witnesses who say you did nothing wrong, we have a paid expert who will testify against you and say you were negligent in causing the incident which resulted in your injuries.”
Excuse No. 2:            “No independent witness saw what happened so we are not going to believe your side of the story.”
Excuse No. 3:            “Even though the doctors and therapists treating you have verified the serious nature of your injuries, we have paid one of our doctors to review your medical records and examine you in this case. He will testify that your injuries aren’t as serious as your doctors think.”
Excuse No. 4:            “We have paid one of our doctors to review your medical records and examine you in this case. He will testify that your injuries were caused by something other than the incident in which you were involved.”
Excuse No. 5:            “We have paid one of our doctors to review your medical records and examine you in this case. He will testify that you were not injured in the incident. Your problems were caused by the natural aging process.”
Excuse No. 6:            “We have paid one of our doctors to review your medical records and examine you in this case. He will testify that you had a pre-existing problem and the incident had nothing to do with the problems you’re having now.”
Excuse No. 7:            “You stayed off of work too long. We have paid one of our doctors to review your medical records and examine you in this case. He will testify that you could have returned to work sooner than you did.”
Excuse No. 8:            “Your fractures have healed and we will not compensate you for the arthritis which has formed because, sooner or later, most people get arthritis.”
At Sarkisian Law Offices we know the excuses insurance companies use and know what arguments are valid and which are not. Having an experienced personal injury attorney in your corner is crucial to make sure you receive proper compensation to cover the effects of your injury. Don't go it alone. If you have been hurt in an accident, give the family of personal injury attorneys at Sarkisian Law Offices a call for a no-cost, no-pressure case evaluation. There is no fees involved until we win your case. Let our family helps yours.

Attorney reviewing a contract with a client across a desk in a law office
By Sarkisian Law Offices September 15, 2026
What to ask in a free consultation with an Indiana injury lawyer, from contingency fees and case costs to comparative fault and filing deadlines.
Two cars after a rear-end collision on a Northwest Indiana road
By Sarkisian Law Offices September 8, 2026
Is the rear driver always at fault in an Indiana rear-end crash? Not always. Learn how comparative fault, brake-checking, and evidence decide who pays.
Front wheel of a black motorcycle parked on a sunlit paved street
By Sarkisian Law Offices September 3, 2026
Indiana insurers assume riders were reckless before reviewing evidence. See how that bias cuts settlements and what evidence pushes back.
Severely damaged white sedan after a crash on a Merrillville street, with another car nearby.
By Sarkisian Law Offices September 1, 2026
Worried about the cost of a lawyer after a rear-end accident in Indiana? Learn how contingency fees work and why most injury victims pay nothing upfront.
Person with an arm in a cast recovering after a car accident
By leeann1027 August 25, 2026
Broken bones are common in Indiana car crashes. Learn the most frequent fracture types, treatment, and the compensation you can recover after a wreck.
Damaged silver car with crumpled front end on roadside after a crash
By Sarkisian Law Offices June 16, 2026
Hit by a driver who fled in Northwest Indiana? Learn who pays for your injuries and how to protect your claim. Free consultation. No fee unless we win.
Show More