Why You Shouldn't Deal With The Insurance Company Alone After a Serious Car Crash

May 14, 2025

After a serious car crash, the last thing you need is to be pressured into accepting less than you deserve. Yet that’s exactly what insurance companies often aim for. Their job is to protect their profits, not your recovery.

Settling a claim without legal guidance can result in a payout that doesn’t come close to covering your medical bills, lost wages, or long-term care needs. Here’s why working with an experienced personal injury attorney is one of the most important decisions you can make.


Understanding Your Legal Rights After a Crash

If you’ve been seriously injured in a car accident, you have rights under Indiana personal injury law. These include the right to seek compensation for your injuries, the right to legal representation, and the right to decline giving recorded statements to insurance companies without your attorney present.

Understanding these rights early can prevent costly mistakes. Many injury victims unknowingly waive or jeopardize their claims by speaking too soon or accepting low settlements. A personal injury lawyer helps you assert and protect your legal rights every step of the way.


How Insurance Companies Work Against You

Insurance companies use a range of strategies to minimize payouts. They might:

  • Downplay the severity of your injuries
  • Dispute the necessity of your treatment
  • Suggest you were partially at fault
  • Delay the process to pressure a quick settlement
  • Misrepresent policy terms to confuse your options

These tactics are designed to wear you down and push you into accepting less. An experienced attorney can anticipate these moves and respond with a well-documented, strategic case.


How Insurance Adjusters Are Trained to Undervalue Claims

Insurance adjusters are professionally trained to protect the company’s bottom line. They often take a friendly, conversational approach, but their goal is to gather information that can be used to reduce your payout.

They might ask leading questions, downplay your injuries, or get you to admit uncertainty about what happened. Some adjusters offer quick settlements, hoping you’ll accept before fully understanding your injuries. Others delay processing your claim, increasing pressure to settle.

They are not your advocates. That’s why having legal counsel is critical before speaking with an adjuster.


Mistakes People Make When Handling Claims Alone

Without legal help, it’s easy to make mistakes that weaken your claim. Some of the most common missteps include:

  • Giving too much information to the insurance adjuster
  • Accepting the first settlement offer
  • Failing to document medical visits, lost wages, or pain
  • Making casual remarks that are later used against you

These errors can cost you thousands. Having a lawyer ensures you avoid these pitfalls from the start.


Emotional and Financial Toll

Dealing with an insurance company alone can be mentally and emotionally draining. The stress of paperwork, phone calls, and negotiation, on top of your physical recovery, can be overwhelming.

Many people settle early just to make the process end. Unfortunately, those quick settlements rarely cover long-term needs like future medical care or lost earning capacity. A lawyer helps protect your financial future and gives you peace of mind during an already difficult time.


Key Evidence That Strengthens Your Injury Claim

Strong evidence is crucial to winning a personal injury claim. Your attorney will help you gather and organize key documentation, such as:

  • Police reports
  • Medical records and treatment plans
  • Photos of the accident scene and injuries
  • Witness statements
  • Documentation of lost wages
  • Expert opinions (e.g., accident reconstructionists or medical experts)

Having complete, organized evidence can be the difference between a denied claim and a full, fair settlement.


How a Personal Injury Lawyer Strengthens Your Case

A qualified personal injury attorney brings much more than legal knowledge—they bring strategy, support, and results. They can:

  • Handle all communications with the insurance company
  • Build a strong claim with evidence and expert input
  • Calculate the full value of your losses, including future costs
  • Negotiate aggressively to get the compensation you deserve

They know how insurance companies operate—and how to push back effectively.


How Lawyers Handle Communication with Insurers

One of the first benefits of hiring a lawyer is that you no longer have to deal directly with the insurance company. Your attorney will:

  • Filter all requests and questions
  • Respond on your behalf with legally sound language
  • Prevent adjusters from twisting your words
  • Manage timing to ensure your case moves forward

This removes the pressure from you and protects the integrity of your claim.


What Not to Say to an Insurance Adjuster

Even innocent remarks can hurt your claim. Avoid:

  • Admitting fault
  • Speculating about the accident
  • Downplaying your injuries

Let your attorney communicate on your behalf. They’ll ensure nothing is said that can be used against you.


The True Value of a Serious Injury Case

Many people underestimate how much a personal injury case is truly worth. An experienced lawyer knows how to evaluate:

  • Immediate medical bills and treatment costs
  • Projected future care (rehab, surgeries, therapies)
  • Lost income and reduced earning potential
  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional trauma and reduced quality of life

Without legal guidance, you may accept far less than you deserve.


Real-World Consequences of Going It Alone

Consider this example: John was in a serious crash and accepted the insurer’s first offer, thinking it would be enough. Months later, his medical bills doubled, and he was left paying out of pocket. Had he consulted an attorney, his settlement would have reflected the true cost of his recovery.

This story is common—and avoidable.


The Long-Term Impact of Settling Too Soon

A fast settlement might feel like relief, but it often leads to:

  • Out-of-pocket medical expenses
  • Debt from ongoing rehab or treatment
  • Loss of income with no compensation for future wages
  • Emotional stress from financial instability

A lawyer ensures the settlement reflects your present and future needs—protecting your long-term well-being.


When to Contact an Attorney After a Crash

The best time to contact a lawyer is immediately after receiving medical care. Insurance companies often reach out within days of an accident—sometimes even hours. The sooner you hire legal representation, the better protected you are from early mistakes or manipulative tactics. Your lawyer will step in to preserve evidence, manage communication, and develop your case from the beginning.


Why Legal Representation Matters

1. Experience and Strategy
They understand the law, know how insurers operate, and are prepared to fight for you.

2. Maximized Compensation
They can uncover damages you may not have considered, like long-term therapy or reduced earning potential.

3. Peace of Mind
With an attorney handling your case, you can focus on recovery, not paperwork and pressure tactics.


The aftermath of a serious accident is stressful enough. Don’t let the insurance company add to it by pressuring you into a bad settlement.

With a personal injury lawyer on your side, you’re not just another claim—you’re a person with rights and a future worth protecting.

If you’ve been seriously injured in a car crash, don’t go it alone. Contact the trusted attorneys at Sarkisian Law Offices today to schedule a complimentary case evaluation to protect your claim, your recovery, and your peace of mind.


September 12, 2025
When you've been injured in a car accident caused by someone else's negligence, you deserve fair compensation for your losses. However, getting the maximum settlement from insurance companies is rarely straightforward. Insurance adjusters are trained to minimize payouts, and often take advantage of accident victims who don't understand their rights or the true value of their claims. This is where an experienced car accident attorney becomes invaluable. At Sarkisian Law Offices , we understand the tactics insurance companies use, and we know how to counter them effectively to maximize your car accident claim. Our team has helped countless accident victims recover the full compensation they deserve, and we're committed to fighting for your rights every step of the way. Understanding the True Value of Your Car Accident Claim Don't settle for the first offer from auto insurance companies, as it's often far below your claim's worth. A skilled car accident lawyer evaluates your claim comprehensively, considering all the ways the accident has affected your life. They work with medical experts to project future medical needs, ensuring your settlement covers ongoing treatment and rehabilitation. They also calculate lost wages and reduced earning capacity, including long-term impacts. Additionally, lawyers effectively document and present pain and suffering claims, demonstrating the accident's impact on your quality of life. By hiring an experienced attorney, they'll seek fair compensation for both tangible and intangible losses. This approach helps you receive the maximum settlement you deserve, covering current and future needs. How Insurance Companies Try to Reduce Your Settlement Insurance adjusters are not on your side, despite how friendly and helpful they may seem. Their job is to save their company money by paying out as little as possible on claims. One of the most common tactics is to make a quick settlement offer before you fully understand the extent of your injuries or have had time to consult with an attorney. These offers are almost always far below the true value of your claim, but they're presented as generous and time-sensitive to pressure you into accepting. Insurance companies often claim that your medical treatment was unnecessary, excessive, or unrelated to the accident. They may argue that you had pre-existing conditions that caused your current problems, or that you're exaggerating your symptoms. They also might use delay tactics, hoping financial pressure will force you to accept a lower settlement. The insurers may claim they need more documentation, request unnecessary medical examinations, or simply take their time responding to communications. Insurers might try to blame you for the accident, as partial blame allows them to reduce their liability and your compensation. Never accept wrongful accusations of blame, as it can deprive you of what you deserve. When you have a car accident attorney handling your case, these delay tactics become less effective. Your lawyer can apply pressure to move the case forward and ensure that delays don't work against you. The Investigation Process That Builds Strong Cases One of the most important ways a car accident lawyer maximizes your claim is with a thorough investigation. The more evidence your attorney can gather to support your case, the stronger your position becomes in settlement negotiations. Accident Scene Analysis Even if the police investigated your accident, your attorney will conduct their own investigation. This might include visiting the accident scene, taking photographs, measuring skid marks, and identifying factors contributing to the crash. Sometimes this investigation reveals evidence that wasn't included in the police report, such as traffic signal timing, road conditions, or visibility issues that help prove the other driver's fault. Witness Statements Witness testimony can be invaluable in car accident cases, especially when there's a dispute about how the accident happened. However, witness memories fade over time, and people move away or become harder to contact. Car accident attorneys move quickly to identify and interview witnesses while their memories are still fresh. They know how to ask the right questions to get useful information and how to document witness statements in a way that will be persuasive to insurance companies or juries. Expert Analysis Complex car accident cases often require expert testimony to explain technical aspects of the crash, such as vehicle speeds, impact forces, or mechanical failures. Car accident lawyers have relationships with qualified experts who can analyze the evidence and provide professional opinions that support your case. This expert analysis is particularly important in cases involving serious injuries, commercial vehicles, or disputed fault situations. Negotiation Skills That Get Results Insurance companies negotiate car accident settlements every day. They have experienced adjusters and attorneys who know how to minimize payouts. To get fair compensation, you need someone on your side who understands the negotiation process just as well. Presenting a Compelling Case Effective negotiation starts with presenting your case in the strongest possible way. This means organizing all the evidence, medical records, and documentation in a format that clearly shows the other driver's responsibility and the full extent of your damages. Car accident attorneys know how to present this information persuasively, highlighting the strongest aspects of your case while addressing any potential weaknesses before the insurance company can exploit them. Understanding Settlement Timing Knowing when to negotiate and when to wait is vital in car accident cases. Settling too early might mean accepting less compensation than you deserve, but waiting too long can sometimes weaken your position. Experienced car accident lawyers understand the factors that affect settlement timing and can advise you on the best strategy for your specific situation. Leverage in Negotiations Insurance companies are more likely to offer fair settlements when they know you're represented by an attorney who's willing and able to take the case to trial if necessary. This gives your lawyer leverage in negotiations you wouldn't have on your own. Choose Sarkisian Law Offices to Maximize Your Indiana Car Accident Claim Sarkisian Law Offices, maximizes compensation in car accident claims by understanding the local legal system and building strong cases. We take a personal interest in each case, working on a contingency fee basis, so you only pay legal fees if we win. We'll protect your rights, handle legal details, and fight for the settlement you deserve. Contact us today at 219-942-7171 or online to learn how we can pursue the compensation you need to move forward. Let us advocate for you while you focus on recovering from your accident.
disability after car accident
July 28, 2025
Learn what compensation you may be entitled to after a car accident resulting in a permanent disability—including medical costs, lost wages, pain & suffering.
Mistakes to Avoid in a Personal Injury Case
June 27, 2025
Avoid costly mistakes after an accident. Learn why having a personal injury attorney matters. Sarkisian Law Offices explains your rights and next steps.
Car Accident Cases
May 31, 2025
Insurance settlements can be complicated, especially when injuries are involved. Make sure you know your rights and how the process works before signing anything.
Car Accident Claim Settlements
September 6, 2024
Navigating the aftermath of a car accident can be daunting. Especially when it comes to understanding the complexities of a car accident settlement. Sarkisan Law Offices is here to help.
Car Accident
July 10, 2024
Choosing the right car accident injury lawyer is crucial to the success of your case. By considering factors such as experience, reputation, communication, and fees, you can find a lawyer who will effectively represent your interests and help you secure the compensation you deserve.
Show More