Should I accept the initial settlement offer from an insurance company?

September 21, 2020

After a catastrophic event, whether it be a workplace accident, serious injury, motor vehicle accident, injury on another’s property or severe harm from a defective or dangerous product, you likely will hear from the at-fault person’s insurance company soon after.

 
As you take care of the aftermath of the accident, this settlement offer adds extra confusion. The reality is, this initial settlement offer from the insurance company will only be a fraction of the full extent of the damages you suffered.

 

Figure the full cost of your injuries

When assessing the full cost of the accident, you need to think about several questions:

These factors, along with expenses such as your initial emergency medical care and ongoing medical treatment, begin to show a better picture of how your serious injury truly impacted you.

How you should proceed

You should never accept a settlement without first consulting with an attorney. The insurance company contacts you right after the injury as a business strategy. The lowball settlement offer will not cover the extent of your financial burden.

The insurance company will hold you to any sort of agreement to the offer even if you have not signed a release or deposited the check, so do not accept it in any way, even verbally.

Damaged silver car with crumpled front end on roadside after a crash
By Sarkisian Law Offices June 16, 2026
Hit by a driver who fled in Northwest Indiana? Learn who pays for your injuries and how to protect your claim. Free consultation. No fee unless we win.
Car Accident with Injuries
February 18, 2026
Thinking of handling your accident claim alone? Learn why that's risky and how insurance companies take advantage of unrepresented victims at Sarkisian Law.
February 6, 2026
What's your motorcycle accident case worth in Indiana? Learn how damages are calculated and what factors affect your compensation at Sarkisian Law.
January 9, 2026
Can multiple parties be at fault for your Indiana accident? Learn how shared liability works and how it affects your compensation at Sarkisian Law.
Truck Accident
December 29, 2025
How long do you have to file a claim after an Indiana truck accident? Learn about critical deadlines that can destroy your case at Sarkisian Law.
December 4, 2025
Learn how federal trucking regulations impact truck accident cases and liability. Sarkisian Law helps victims hold trucking companies accountable.
Show More